Skip to content
All posts

The biggest margin is usually a trap

Why a 5% flip can beat a 48% one, and how to tell a real spread from a planted one.

, 4 min read

Sort any flip list by margin and the top of it looks like free coins. It almost never is. A margin says what you make if you sell one. It says nothing about whether anyone will buy it.

Two items

Both made up, both priced the way the bazaar page does it:

The big marginThe small one
Buy order101,230
Sell offer151,310
Profit each, after tax4.863.6
Margin48%5.2%
Bought per week40400,000
If you get 1 sale in 100nothing4,000 sales, 254k
If you get every sale193 coinsyou will not

The first item pays 193 coins a week if every single buyer picks you. The second pays a thousand times that for one sale in a hundred. Margin ranked them the wrong way round.

Planted spreads

Some big margins are there on purpose. Someone holds most of an item, lists it at several times its usual price, and waits for a flip list to show the gap. You place a buy order, they sell into it, and you own a pile of something nobody buys at that price.

A drawing with example numbers, not live data.

Illustration with example prices: an item’s price runs level for days, then jumps to more than four times that. The jump is marked as a flagged price.

SkyCofl marks prices that look like this and SkyTools hides them until you ask. The mark is a judgement, so it can miss one. These are the signs to look for yourself:

  • The price history is level for days and then a cliff.
  • The order book has almost nothing between the two prices.
  • Weekly volume is tiny next to how many are listed.
  • You have never heard of the item.

A better way to look

  1. Sort by coins per hour on the bazaar page. It already weighs how fast things fill.
  2. Set a weekly volume floor. 100k or more keeps out most of what will not move.
  3. Open the item and look at a week of history before you look at the profit.
  4. Order a little. Watch how long it takes. Then order a lot, or don’t.

The overview does the first two for you: it leaves out flagged prices and anything under 5,000 instant buys a week. The rest is in the bazaar docs.

Read next

  • Auctions

    Reading a lowest BIN

    Four numbers to check before you trust the cheapest listing, and what the auction house keeps.

    , 5 min read

  • Flips

    Craft, forge, NPC or Kat?

    What each kind of flip asks of you: coins, time, attention or luck.

    , 5 min read

  • Minions

    What a minion really pays

    Payback, full storage and hoppers: the three things a coins-per-day ranking hides.

    , 4 min read